When we picture chocolate making, we think of flowing chocolate, turning stones, moulds being filled. Sorting the beans is not one of those images. Yet it is one of the stages we take most seriously at the workshop.
When a lot arrives, we start by looking at what is really in front of us. The sacks hold beans that have been harvested, fermented, dried, transported and handled several times over. Even when selection at origin has been careful, a sack is never a perfectly uniform whole.
What we take out
First, what is not cacao: the stones and fragments that have travelled with the beans. Removing them is a matter of quality, hygiene and protecting the equipment. A stone has no business in a stone grinder.
Then, two kinds of beans: flat ones, which never really developed in the pod, and mouldy ones. A single mouldy bean can mark the flavour of a whole lot. The rest are the good beans, the ones that will carry the intended profile.
Sorting does not mean making everything uniform. Cacao is a living agricultural material: a difference in size, shape or colour is not necessarily a defect. Knowing how to tell a natural variation from a real problem is precisely the craft.

A simple gesture, repeated
On a tray, the hands move at the pace of the beans. We slide, we turn over, we look more closely. The gesture repeats, the attention stays the same. There is nothing mystical about it: it is a concrete operation, with a clear purpose.
Sorting comes before everything else. Then comes roasting, low, or no roasting at all depending on the chosen profile; then cracking and winnowing, which produce the nibs; then the stone grinder, where texture and time come into play in a different way.

Why show it?
Because a smooth bar always ends up making us forget the bean it comes from. Chocolate is uniform; the raw material is not. Between the two lie dozens of decisions, some of them tiny.
Showing hands sorting does not mean this method is better than others. Depending on volumes, producers and workshops use manual or mechanical tools, and many do a first sort at origin. We are simply showing what we do here, and why.
Quality does not rest on one grand final gesture. It is built in these modest decisions, made long before the cacao looks anything like chocolate. The workshop's other gestures are described in From bean to bar and on The workshop page.
Opening photo: Kat Colson.
